Colin Mizuo Toenail Lawsuit Portland: Full Case Details & $38M Update

The Colin Mizuo toenail lawsuit has been followed closely by many Portland families since June. However, a major development has occurred in the case. A second patient has come forward and stated that the podiatrist injected rubbing alcohol into her toe as opposed to the intended numbing agent. This means we have two women with two separate lawsuits based on a single, routine procedure that should have only taken a few minutes. This is why this story is spreading quickly through Oregon and other parts of the country.

This article is an overview of everything that has been reported about these lawsuits. I will tell you who filed the lawsuit, what each complaint states, what Kaiser Permanente has responded to the complaints, and what the financial damages claim means. Additionally, I am going to explain the “$38 million” figure that you may have read about online. I will also provide you with several practical ways to protect yourself from similar problems when having a foot procedure.

A very significant point should be made prior to our starting. All of the claims presented here are taken from lawsuits and news stories. Lawsuits are allegations, they are not verdicts, and as of this date, no court has rendered a decision on either of these cases. Therefore, throughout the article, we will use terms such as “alleges” and “based upon the complaint,” because that is where the facts exist at this time.

Table of Contents

  • Quick Summary of the Case
  • Who Is Dr. Colin Mizuo?
  • The First Lawsuit: Sarah Blackman
  • The Second Lawsuit: Judith Young
  • Case Timeline at a Glance
  • The Money: $13M, $23M, and the “$38M” Question
  • What Kaiser Permanente Has Said
  • What Dr. Mizuo and The Oregon Clinic Have Said
  • Why Injected Rubbing Alcohol Is Dangerous
  • How a Toenail Procedure Should Work
  • How Could a Mix-Up Like This Happen?
  • What Happens Next in Court
  • How to Protect Yourself Before a Foot Procedure
  • If You Think a Medical Error Hurt You
  • What This Case Means for Patient Trust
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Final Thoughts
  • Sources and Editorial Note

Quick Summary of the Case

Busy readers will find a summary at the top of this article. Below, you will find a list of the key facts confirmed by several different news organizations.

DetailWhat reports say
Doctor namedDr. Colin Mizuo, a podiatrist
Location of proceduresKaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center, Hillsboro, Oregon (Portland area)
ProceduresIngrown toenail removals, January 2026
First lawsuitSarah Blackman and her husband, Jason Fleskes; filed June 2026; $13 million
Second lawsuitJudith Young and her husband, Thomas; filed November 9, 2026; $23 million
Combined amount sought$36 million (a demand, not an award)
Core allegationRubbing alcohol (70% isopropyl) went into the toe instead of lidocaine
DefendantsDr. Mizuo and Kaiser-related entities
Patients’ attorneyLaura Kalur, who represents both women
Case statusPending; no court findings yet

As you can see, there is a clear trend in both cases. Both surgeries occurred within approximately one week of each other, in the same hospital and were performed by the same physician. This commonality among the two cases is what allows the attorney to refer to these events as trends as opposed to single occurrences.

Who Is Dr. Colin Mizuo?

Dr. Colin Mizuo is a Podiatrist that provides services to people throughout the Portland Area. According to public provider profiles, Dr. Mizuo is listed as a Doctor of Podiatric Medicine. According to Dr. Mizuo’s Hospital Profile, Dr. Mizuo has worked in Trauma, Reconstruction, Limb Preservation, and Sports Medicine. Additionally, according to Dr. Mizuo’s Hospital Profile, Dr. Mizuo has participated in reviewing scientific literature for a Professional Foot and Ankle Society. This indicates that Dr. Mizuo has participated in the academic aspect of his profession.

The reason his name is listed in the lawsuit(s) is due to the fact that he was the physician who performed the January 2026 operations at Kaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center. In addition, the Oregon Clinic, who is his employer, released a statement in July regarding the lawsuit against a Kaiser facility and that he was involved.

At this point, we are attempting to provide an objective perspective. There is no documentation within the public records we have reviewed that supports the claims made against him. As far as can be determined, he has not addressed publicly either of the lawsuits filed against him. In light of these facts, it would be appropriate for our readers to consider his side of the story as undocumented until such time as he provides additional information regarding his position..

The First Lawsuit: Sarah Blackman

The initial lawsuit against Dr. Mizuo and Kaiser Permanente was filed by Sarah Blackman, a Washington County resident, and her husband, Jason Fleskes, seeking damages of $13 million. The lawsuit was filed in June 2026.

What the complaint describes

According to the news reporting about the lawsuit, Blackman visited Kaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center on Jan. 29, 2026. Blackman was at Kaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center to receive treatment for her ingrown toenails located on the second toe of both feet. Toenail removal is typically performed by injecting lidocaine (or another type of anesthetic) into the toe. The anesthetic numbs the toe so the patient can feel only pressure, not pain.

Blackman states the doctor used rubbing alcohol in place of the local anesthetic. Her complaint states that even though the procedure began, she screamed and cried during the removal of her first toe. She then asked the doctor to stop before continuing with the removal of her second toe. In addition to being told to “just get over it,” Blackman’s lawsuit claims the doctor also stated he had to go because he was in a hurry to leave. Reports vary regarding how they quote this statement, so we have paraphrased it above.

The plaintiff states that she suffered swelling, pain, and discoloration in her toes after treatment. Her symptoms led her to seek emergency care. Clinicians at the emergency room initially thought that she might have an infection. According to the lawsuit, Kaiser notified the plaintiff in March that instead of anesthetic being applied to her toes, rubbing alcohol was used.

The detail that changed the case

The unusual nature of this lawsuit lies in the fact that, in its July 24 court filing, Kaiser’s attorneys admitted that Blackman received isopropyl alcohol instead of lidocaine. Additionally, according to reporting on IBTimes UK, Kaiser’s attorneys stated that the substitution was unknown to the defendant(s) and that a defendant(s) breached the standard of care.

In simple terms, Kaiser did not challenge the fundamental facts of Blackman’s case. This was only about how she was treated. It didn’t deal with the separate claims that Judith Young has made. However, many readers will find this to be an important event, since defendants rarely admit that they have done something wrong at such an early stage.

The Second Lawsuit: Judith Young

On Monday, November 9, 2026, the second complaint was filed. Judith and Thomas Young are asking for $23 million. While local media outlets are consistent in reporting the facts surrounding this case, they differ on which county the complaint was filed in. KOIN reported that the complaint was filed in Multnomah County Circuit Court, and KPTV stated that it was filed in Washington County. For clarity purposes, we will refer to this as an Oregon State Court filing.

What Young alleges

On January 22, 2026, the week before Blackman visited the medical center, Young also visited the medical center. At this time she was there to have her ingrown toenail treated. Young is alleging through her lawsuit that Dr. Mizuo used about four milliliters of 70% isopropyl alcohol to numb her toe instead of lidocaine.

The lawsuit claims that the woman screamed and cried from the pain caused by the injections. The lawsuit further states that the doctor continued to perform the procedure even though it was apparent that the injections were causing extreme discomfort. In addition, the lawsuit states that the doctor did not verify if the woman’s toe was numb before continuing the procedure. After completing the procedure, the lawsuit claims that the doctor informed the woman that her toe may become blistered; however, the doctor did not inform her of the substance used for the injection.

The aftermath she describes

Young said that when she returned home from the hospital her toe became inflamed and turned black. Young went to the ER on four separate occasions within a few weeks. Clinicians initially believed Young had an infection as opposed to something related to the alcohol use since they did not know about the alcohol.

She also stated that she has diabetes, and this caused concern for how long it would take for her to heal. For approximately four months, she suffered from pain, received continuous wound care, and had damaged tissue removed. Additionally, she was unable to attend work due to her injuries.

Around March 2, Young stated that the head of podiatry at Kaiser contacted her to inform her of what had occurred. He allegedly informed her that this was a “fortunate error” and provided her with a written statement regarding the incident. The lawsuit filed by Young alleges that she received no such written response from the doctor. Additionally, her medical records indicated that the incident was a complication of the toenail procedure.

The complaint uses very strong terms regarding the harmful effects of alcohol on cells; it refers to alcohol as being a “perfect cellular killer.” According to the complaint, blisters do not typically occur with a correctly performed local anesthesia procedure. Additionally, the use of rubbing alcohol may lead to chemical burns.

Case Timeline at a Glance

Dates matter in any legal story, so we organized them below.

DateEvent
January 22, 2026Judith Young has an ingrown toenail procedure at Kaiser Westside Medical Center
January 29, 2026Sarah Blackman has two ingrown toenails removed at the same facility
Around March 2026Kaiser’s head of podiatry tells both women about the alleged alcohol injection
June 2026Blackman and Fleskes file a $13 million lawsuit
July 2026The Oregon Clinic issues a statement about the lawsuit
July 24, 2026Kaiser’s lawyers acknowledge in a response that Blackman received isopropyl alcohol instead of lidocaine
November 9, 2026Young and her husband file a $23 million lawsuit
November 10–12, 2026Local and national outlets report on the second lawsuit; Kaiser says it will review Young’s care

During the period from March when the disclosures were made until June and November when the filings occurred, both women continued to experience pain and financial burden due to their medical care. This timeframe illustrates why each complaint emphasizes how long it took to receive responses.

The Money: $13M, $23M, and the “$38M” Question

I’m sure you’ve noticed that newspapers often use large numbers when reporting news. There are many large numbers in this article as well, but because these numbers can sometimes confuse us, I want to take a moment to look at them individually.

What the reported figures add up to

The Blackman-Fleskes pair is seeking $13 million; the Youngs (husband & wife) are seeking $23 million. Together these total $36 million. Many reputable news organizations (such as IBTimes UK) have reported on this total amount of money, and have emphasized that neither of those two amounts were awarded by a court.

Where does “$38 million” come from?

The “$38M” figure is used in some search results and social media postings. We have done extensive searches and cannot locate any court filing or credible news reporting that supports this figure. The total amount of the claims filed against the company is $36 million. There may be a third lawsuit, an amended complaint, or a basic mathematical calculation error that resulted in the higher figure, however, we were unable to find anything to support these possibilities.

We believe that providing accurate information is more important than having an eye catching figure, particularly since there are real individuals and a real doctor’s reputation at stake. Therefore, we have used $36 million in our report. We will be updating this page immediately if another credible source of data emerges.

Demand versus damages

The demand is the total sum that a plaintiff is seeking in damages. The majority of the time, the court, settlement, or jury will award the plaintiff less than their original demand. Also, there are specific laws within Oregon and the unique circumstances surrounding each case that determine what a plaintiff may ultimately receive. Therefore, a $23 million demand indicates to you how seriously the plaintiff’s attorney believes the harm caused by the defendant was, but it does not indicate what the outcome will be.

What Kaiser Permanente Has Said

Kaiser has made public statements, though they remain fairly short.

After the second lawsuit, a spokesperson for Kaiser stated that patient safety is the number one priority for the organization and that they take seriously all complaints regarding their service. In addition, the spokesperson said Kaiser will evaluate Young’s treatment and make adjustments as necessary to correct any problems that are discovered. Reports have indicated that Kaiser did not respond to requests for comments following the first lawsuit.

The most revealing document is not a press statement, however; it was Kaiser’s attorney’s July 24 response to Blackman’s lawsuit. In that response, Kaiser admitted the replacement of alcohol for lidocaine and stated that Kaiser breached its duty of care. This admission was a strong stance on the fundamental issues in the case. However, this filing does not answer other important questions like: How much damage did the plaintiff suffer? Who is responsible for the damages? What is the appropriate amount of money to compensate the plaintiff for their losses? These are the types of questions that will determine where the case goes next.

What Dr. Mizuo and The Oregon Clinic Have Said

Multiple news agencies have reported that Dr. Mizuo has made no public statement regarding the lawsuits or comments on them. He is being advised by attorneys to make no public statements while there are still ongoing legal proceedings.

In July of 2026, the clinic where Dr. Mizuo works (The Oregon Clinic) released a brief press release stating that they were aware of a lawsuit filed against Kaiser Permanente based on an alleged medical mistake by Dr. Mizuo. The press release stated that he is currently employed by The Oregon Clinic, however, it did not comment on whether or not the allegations are valid.

A single news source has stated that there are no public records of any disciplinary action taken by the Oregon Medical Board regarding this individual. Since records may be altered, it would be best for individuals seeking up-to-date information on his licensure status to check the Oregon Medical Board’s online licensure search tool.

Why Injected Rubbing Alcohol Is Dangerous

We all recognize rubbing alcohol as a way to clean our skin. When we use rubbing alcohol to prep our skin prior to receiving an injection, the alcohol dries fast. However, injecting rubbing alcohol directly into tissues would be completely different.

Isopropyl alcohol damages cells. When it enters tissue, it may irritate nerves, damage blood vessels, and destroy surrounding cells. Although doctors occasionally employ highly regulated, alcohol-based injections as part of targeted, specialized medical treatment regimens, the alcohol used in these types of procedures has significantly different concentrations, amounts, and methods of delivery than what would be employed for routine anesthesia. Additionally, because a toe is so small, a relatively minor amount of a harmful chemical solution is able to concentrate in a confined area.

The lawsuits describe what kind of problems you would have if you were injured by chemicals:

  • severe pain during the procedure
  • blistering and skin color changes afterward
  • tissue damage that needed wound care and debridement
  • trouble walking and working
  • lasting nerve-related symptoms, according to some reports

We aren’t making diagnoses for anyone. Only the patient’s doctor will be able to provide details regarding their specific injury. However, the scientific principles used to help understand the reasons why each woman is describing an extreme amount of pain and is taking a long time to heal are explained below.

How a Toenail Procedure Should Work

To understand how things could have potentially gone wrong, it would be useful to first examine what typically goes well. The process of removing an ingrown toenail is a very common minor procedure performed by podiatrists on a regular basis. Patients are able to return home after having this procedure done.

Before the Numbing Injection

A standard visit usually starts with these steps:

  • Assessment. Your doctor will review the status of your toe, look for signs of infection and review your medical records to see if you have had other illnesses like diabetes.
  • The doctor will explain the procedure, its possible side effects, and how to take care of yourself after the procedure. Once both parties agree that you want to go through with the procedure, then we can begin.
  • Anesthesia. After cleaning the skin of the toe, the doctor applies a local anesthetic (typically lidocaine) directly above the nail beds of the affected toes. This procedure is known as a digital block.

During and After the Removal

  • Checking the numbness. To properly perform surgery on your toe, it should be confirmed that the toe is numb prior to starting the procedure. Most doctors will wait for a couple of minutes after applying local anesthetic, then use a light touch or a small pinch to determine if the toe is completely numb.
  • The doctor will remove the bad part of the nail, and may treat the nail root to prevent recurrence of the issue.
  • Aftercare for the Toe Bandage. The group has bandaged the toe and instructed the patient on maintaining cleanliness of the area.

What Patients Should and Should Not Feel

When people get the numbing shot, they typically experience some burning sensation and then a feeling of pressure. During the removal of the toenail, there should be no sharp pain. If a patient shouts, screams, or states that their toe is not numb enough to continue with the procedure, it is expected that the physician will cease working on the toenail and determine whether the area has received sufficient anesthesia. The two complaints both claim that this did not occur.

How Could a Mix-Up Like This Happen?

The most frequently asked question by our readers is, “How does someone make a mistake in selecting a liquid?” While we cannot determine what occurred during this incident, the court will review all available evidence. Patient safety experts have been studying errors in prescribing drugs for many years, and many of those risk factors apply to hospitals.

  • Look-alike containers. Clear liquids in similar syringes or cups look the same.
  • Every single syringe and cup that is used on the sterile field must be labeled by each team. This is required under medication safety guidelines. Failing to do this increases the potential for misidentification.
  • Time pressure. Rushed rooms invite shortcuts.
  • The single-person task. A second person’s view may find a mistake prior to the patient being exposed to the problem.
  • The missing of warning signs, unusual pain, or a patient who is protesting loudly, should cause you to pause.

The filings stated that Kaiser’s lawyers referred to the substitution as unintentional. Therefore, this indicates that the complaint was based upon an error, not intentionality. Regardless of whether the error was unintentional or intentional, all patients have the right to receive quality healthcare. These allegations create serious questions concerning the checks and balances used in the operating room.

What Happens Next in Court

The reader should not anticipate a rapid conclusion for civil malpractice lawsuits. The normal sequence of events follows.

  1. The filing of a complaint by the plaintiff, and the subsequent response filed by the defendant(s), are both parts of the pleading process. These processes have begun in each of the cases being heard today.
  2. Discovery. Both sides gather records, email, policy and testimony. Attorneys interview witnesses under oath.
  3. Motions. Parties may ask the judge to narrow issues or dismiss claims.
  4. Most medical malpractice lawsuits are settled prior to going to court, and many times these settlements are kept confidential.
  5. Trial. If no settlement happens, a judge or jury decides liability and damages.

Attorney for the Plaintiffs, Laura Kalur, views the current circumstances as a shocking display of negligent behavior and failure. Additionally, Kalur states that she will be investigating whether there are additional plaintiffs who have experienced similar harms. As long as more individuals step up to report their experiences, then the number of individual claims filed can expand. Conversely, defense attorneys can dispute how severe the injuries were, or the amount of monetary damages awarded, even if the primary error in question is not contested.

We will keep this page current as new filings or statements appear.

How to Protect Yourself Before a Foot Procedure

The majority of toenail surgeries occur without complication. However, the above example demonstrates that patients are also involved in being safe. Patients do not have to pay anything to utilize these practices which may help them identify potential complications at an early stage.

Before the procedure

  • What should I expect? If I were to ask a question like “Which of the numbing medications do you use?”, that would be completely appropriate.
  • You need to tell me about your medical past. Please include information on whether you have diabetes, are experiencing poor circulation, or have allergies. Also let me know if you are taking any medications. Your medical past affects how likely it is that you will heal after surgery.
  • Bring a person along with you. A friend or relative may hear, inquire, and transport you back to your residence.

During the procedure

  • Wait until you can’t feel anything in that area. Once you cannot feel anything, ask the physician to verify that your toe is numb before he/she removes it.
  • Report if you experience any type of discomfort. If you are experiencing sharp pain, burning sensations or had a strong response to the shot, report it immediately and request that the team stops.
  • Do not be afraid of being rude. You have the ability to say “Stop.” Clinical staff who are good will accept this as feedback.

After the procedure

  • Watch for warning signs. If you develop any blisters, skin color changes (darkened or grayish), increased redness around your wound area, excessive swelling, fever, or worsening pain that is not improving with treatment, please seek immediate medical care.
  • Inquire about what occurred. If anything seemed off, request a simple explanation of the issue, and record what the group states.
  • You may ask for your medical records. Under federal law, you have the right to review your own medical records, and obtaining a copy of your records can help you get another doctor’s opinion if needed.

If you have any serious symptoms like a red rash that spreads and is accompanied by a fever, then you should contact your doctor or go to the nearest emergency room immediately. Don’t wait until you have a lawyer’s opinion about whether or not you can sue someone before getting medical attention..

If You Think a Medical Error Hurt You

If a medical procedure results in an unexplained level of pain that causes you to suspect there may have been an error during the process, then this is how to calmly and effectively react.

Get Care and Write Everything Down

First get treated medically. Your health is more important than anything else. When you see your new doctor, let him know exactly what occurred and when it did.

Record the information. Document the date, the staff member(s) you had contact with, your symptoms and the instructions provided by the staff. It is difficult to recall this type of information at a later time.

Collect and Compare Your Records

Hang onto your documentation. Keep all discharge papers, medical bills, images of the injury, and other communications (letters/patient-portal messages).

You can get a copy of your whole chart and then see if that matches what you remember happening. Young, for instance, had a line in her chart saying the incident was a “complication” and that’s why she doesn’t believe the reason she was given.

Report Your Concern and Get Legal Advice

Report. Patients’ safety department, patients’ relations department in hospitals. Complaints regarding physicians licensed by the Oregon Medical Board are received.

Consult with a medical malpractice lawyer. A majority will provide free initial consultations. There are time limits. In Oregon, you normally file a medical malpractice lawsuit within two years of when you discover the harm caused by the alleged negligence, but there are other time restrictions as well. Some of the rules may not apply to you; therefore, it would be best to consult with a licensed attorney regarding your specific case. consult with an attorney regarding specific questions about the law.education rather than legal advice.

What This Case Means for Patient Trust

Beyond the legal issues, this case is about something more profound. Patients put their lives in the hands of healthcare providers, especially during some of their most difficult times. A toenail removal seems minor; therefore, people rarely anticipate risks associated with it. When a typical doctor’s appointment allegedly becomes an ongoing, several-month process, patients lose faith in the system.

The first way healthcare organizations will react to a error is by fixing the problem. The second way is by being open and honest with the patient who was harmed. The women both believe that the information they received from their hospital was very late and did not have enough detail. Some people who advocate for patients state that providing a timely and accurate response to a mistake can help patients recover from harm and may reduce conflict.

However, we must also recognize that one alleged incident does not represent the entirety of a professional field. Every day there are hundreds of thousands of successful and safe treatments performed by both podiatrists and nurses. This means that we should not fear receiving treatment from a podiatrist or nurse. Rather, we need to ask questions, speak out about our concerns, and expect transparency.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Colin Mizuo toenail lawsuit about?

Two women in Oregon say Dr. Colin Mizuo used 70% isopropyl rubbing alcohol on their feet rather than lidocaine when he performed surgery to remove ingrown toenails from each of them in January 2026. The two filed a lawsuit against Dr. Mizuo and Kaiser Permanente alleging negligence and medical malpractice.

How much money do the lawsuits seek?

Sarah Blackman and her husband are seeking $13 million. Judith Young and her husband are seeking $23 million. The total demand is $36 million. No court has made an award of cash.

Is there a $38 million lawsuit?

We couldn’t find a reliable report or filing that supports the $38 million amount. Reliable news sources have reported a total of $36 million.

Where did the procedures happen?

The two procedures were performed at Kaiser Permanente Westside Medical Center, located in Hillsboro, Oregon, a city within the Portland metropolitan area.

Has Kaiser admitted fault?

In a court document filed on July 24th in Blackman’s lawsuit against Kaiser, Kaiser’s attorneys admitted that Blackman was given isopropyl alcohol rather than lidocaine. Additionally, Kaiser’s attorneys admitted that there was a breach of the standard of care by at least one of the defendants. This court document did not address Young’s lawsuit against Kaiser, and Kaiser has stated that they are currently reviewing Young’s medical treatment.

Has Dr. Mizuo responded?

The Oregon Clinic (where he works) made a brief comment regarding the lawsuit, but they did not respond to the allegations made.

Can more patients join the case?

The patients’ lawyer said that they are checking into whether there are other people who may have had similar injuries. If you believe that you have a concern regarding your own injury, then you need to consult with a lawyer who is licensed.

Is it safe to have an ingrown toenail removed?

In most instances, yes. This is a very common and typically fast procedure. However, it would be beneficial for you to inquire about the anesthetic used, ensure your toe is indeed numb prior to the initiation of the procedure, and communicate if you experience sharp pain at any point during the process.

What are warning signs after a toenail procedure?

Watch out for serious or getting worse pain, blister formation, dark or grey skin, red areas spreading, very swollen areas, fluid coming from the area, or fever. If you see any of these signs, seek help from a health care professional right away.

Will this case go to trial?

No one knows what is going to happen next. While most medical malpractice lawsuits are settled prior to trial, there are a few that go on to court. We will continue to keep this article updated as things develop.

Final Thoughts

The Colin Mizuo toenail lawsuit that Portland residents are talking about brings up some very uncomfortable but also important issues regarding patient safety. Two women claim that they were injured and left with long-term problems as a result of a routine procedure. Kaiser admitted to substituting the product in one of the cases and said they will be reviewing the second. Dr. Mizuo has said nothing since this came to light, and the court systems still haven’t determined who is responsible.

While the news is important, the facts are what really count. The total amount asked for by the plaintiffs is $36 million; there was never any award. We intend to maintain the accuracy of this site as the case progresses.

The most important lesson you should learn from this story is that you have a role in managing your health. Inquire about what enters your body; tell people when you hurt; and find help promptly when you feel like there’s an issue.

Read More: The Marsha Linehan Story: How Overcoming BPD Created Life-Saving Therapy